A claimant comes to you eighteen months after an instrumental birth. The file has the operative note, a colorectal opinion on continence and a psychiatric report on birth trauma. It says nothing about sex. She has not had comfortable intercourse since the delivery, her relationship is under strain, and no clinician has asked about it. Sexual dysfunction after childbirth is a recognised consequence of significant perineal trauma, and in my experience it is rarely particularised in the claim.
In short
- Sexual dysfunction after childbirth is well described after third and fourth degree tears, and instrumental birth raises the risk of those tears.
- The research is mixed on how long symptoms last, so persistence and causation need individual assessment.
- A sexual health assessment separates injury effects from ordinary postpartum change and identifies which other specialists are needed.
- Good instructions include the delivery records, a pre-birth baseline and specific questions on nature, severity, prognosis and treatment.
Why this head of damage goes missing
Birth injury claims tend to be built around what is visible in the records: the tear, the repair, the incontinence, the psychiatric diagnosis. Sexual symptoms sit outside that frame. Claimants are embarrassed. Clinicians do not ask. Lawyers reasonably do not raise a topic the claimant has not mentioned.
The literature says the same thing.
One study notes that sexual health problems are common after delivery yet lack professional recognition
, and
Australian commentary on the national perineal tear standard describes tears as a subject that was taboo, with women suffering in silence
. Silence in the records is not evidence of no loss. I discuss the broader pattern in why sexual health is rarely assessed in personal injury claims and in sexual dysfunction as an overlooked head of damage.
Where vacuum and forceps births fit
The injury that matters most here is the obstetric anal sphincter injury, which means a third or fourth degree tear.
These occur in roughly 2 to 6 percent of vaginal births, with a two to three fold increased risk with vacuum births and a four to eight fold increase with forceps
, according to an Australian clinical review.
In 2021 the Australian incidence was reported as 2.7 percent of vaginal births, and 4.5 percent for a first vaginal birth
, per a recent Australian outcomes study.
Tear grade is defined in the national clinical care standard.
Grade 3a, 3b and 3c describe increasing involvement of the external and internal sphincters, and a fourth degree tear also involves the anorectal mucosa.
The grade in the operative note is the starting point for any sexual health opinion.
Sphincter injury is not the only pathway.
Levator ani avulsion is seen more often after forceps than after vacuum deliveries
, according to a Bergen cohort analysis. Whether and how pelvic floor muscle injury affects sexual function is a question for the imaging and urogynaecology evidence, and I defer to those specialties on it.
What the research shows on sexual dysfunction after childbirth
The first systematic review focused on this question pooled 14 studies.
Dyspareunia in the first year after sphincter injury ranged from 27 to 35 percent, and only 40 to 57 percent of women had resumed sexual activity by 3 months
, as reported in this PubMed-indexed review.
A later scoping review of 33 articles found delayed resumption of intercourse, an increased risk of dyspareunia that can persist for years, and in several studies reduced desire, lubrication, orgasm and satisfaction
. That is on the scoping review’s PubMed page.
Australian data point the same way.
A New South Wales retrospective study concluded that physical, psychosocial and sexual symptoms lasted beyond 12 months in more than half the women affected
, and
48 percent of women who went on to have further children reported that their delivery choices were affected
. Both findings are in the full study. Reproductive decisions are part of the sexual health picture and are easy to overlook.
The evidence is not one-directional, and a credible report has to say so.
One review reported that although pain, lubrication problems and difficulty reaching orgasm occur, overall sexual function did not appear influenced in the long term
, per a French review of OASI management.
A 2026 systematic review and meta-analysis was designed to test whether a sphincter injury independently affects postpartum sexual function
, as described on the journal page. Population averages do not decide an individual case. They explain why the expert must examine this claimant’s trajectory and not assume the outcome.
What a sexual health assessment can and cannot establish
In my assessments I address the following:
- Whether a sexual dysfunction is present, and which domains are affected: pain, desire, arousal, orgasm, avoidance.
- Severity, using validated instruments alongside the clinical interview.
The Female Sexual Function Index and the PISQ-12 are the questionnaires most often used in this literature. - Pre-birth baseline, and how much of the change is ordinary postpartum adjustment such as fatigue, breastfeeding and a new baby.
- Causation and contribution, including psychological, relational and pre-existing factors.
- Prognosis, and reasonable and necessary treatment such as sexual therapy and coordination with pelvic floor physiotherapy.
- Partner impact and the effect on future pregnancy decisions.
Some questions belong elsewhere. Tear grade, sphincter integrity and fistula are for colorectal surgery, urogynaecology or imaging. Post-traumatic stress and depression are for psychiatry. Whether obstetric care met the standard is for an obstetrician. I say where my opinion depends on another specialty’s findings, and I write for the court, not for the party who instructed me.
Consent and sexual outcomes
Some birth injury matters raise a question about what the patient was told before an instrumental delivery or episiotomy. The national standard lists
information, shared decision making and informed consent as its first quality statement
. In Australian negligence law, the High Court in Rogers v Whitaker described
a risk as material if a reasonable person in the patient’s position would be likely to attach significance to it, or if the practitioner should be aware this patient would
. State and territory civil liability legislation adds its own provisions, so check the law in your jurisdiction.
A sexologist cannot say whether a warning should have been given. I can address what sexual dysfunction means clinically for a patient in the claimant’s position, and what the literature said about the risk. Breach and causation are for the court, with obstetric evidence.
What to put in your instructions
Instructions that work well for birth injury sexual health assessments include:
- The delivery summary, operative note, tear grade, instruments used, episiotomy details and repair record.
- Discharge summaries and every postnatal review, including any colorectal, urogynaecology or physiotherapy notes.
- Prior obstetric history and any earlier pelvic pain, gynaecological problems or sexual difficulties, because the expert needs a baseline.
- The other expert reports already on file, so the sexual health opinion can rely on them and avoid duplicating them.
- Specific questions: is a sexual dysfunction present, what is its nature and severity, how much is attributable to the birth injury, what is the prognosis, what treatment is reasonable and necessary, and what is the impact on the partner and on family planning.
- Whether a single, joint or tribunal-appointed expert is being sought.
I cover this in more detail in how to brief a sexology expert. Assessments run by secure video after the claimant completes a structured questionnaire. Reports are structured question by question to your instructions and delivered within 10 business days of the claimant assessment. When the report arrives, reading a sexology expert report explains how each section is used in negotiation.
Check the file before the claim is framed
If the claimant has symptoms that no one has recorded, the claim as pleaded may leave out a real loss. A short preliminary conversation can confirm whether a sexual health assessment is worth instructing. Early scoping is also useful because the questions to the other experts are often better framed once the sexual health picture is clear.
If you are considering a sexual health assessment for a birth injury matter, see the medico-legal consultancy services page or email info@arianasexology.com. A complimentary preliminary discussion is available to confirm scope before a formal referral.
If it wasn’t assessed, it wasn’t claimed.
